woman accusing manThis is the next post in my series on the handling of stalking or menacing charges in our area of Ohio. My last article discussed protective orders in Cincinnati stalking and menacing cases. It is important for a defendant to refrain from contacting the victim while a case is pending. Doing so may well result in additional criminal charges. An experienced attorney will assist you with determining the best path forward for your given situation. In this article I will be discussing the fact that such charges are sometimes based on false claims. If you are in need of assistance then contact my office today to speak with a criminal defense lawyer.

False Ohio stalking & menacing charges are sometimes a result of divorce or child custody proceedings

It is, sadly, not uncommon for Ohio stalking or menacing charges to be based on false claims. This is especially true in cases involving divorce or child custody. In such proceedings, a Family Law Judge will consider a history of violence as a factor as to which a parent should obtain custody. As a result, one parent may make false claims against another in an effort to fabricate a criminal case which can then be used in the family law proceedings. It can be common for a defendant to not take such charges seriously, as they know them to be false. It must be understood, however, that prosecutors will take such matters very seriously. Failing to mount a proper defense may result in a conviction.

There can be several ways to address stalking and menacing charges which are based on false or fabricated claims. First, these types of matters often involve conduct which is inconsistent with the accusations that one was afraid for the safety. Examples of this can include evidence that the “victim” was contacting the accused individual and/or evidence that the accuser was in no way attempting to avoid the accused. Second, there may be direct evidence that a claims is false. Examples of this may include evidence showing that the accused person was at work during the time at which it is claimed they were driving by the accuser’s residence. Whether such evidence is enough to show that the claims are false will be up to the finder of the fact (the jury) unless it is enough for the prosecutor to believe that the charges should be dropped.

The foregoing concepts are best explained through an example. Suppose Jane claims that John is calling her repeatedly, to the point that she feels threatened. She provides a screenshot to law enforcement showing that John called more than one hundred times in the course of a week. Law enforcement refers the matter for prosecution and charges are filed. All Jane provided were the phone call records. John provides his lawyer with evidence that Jane texted him repeatedly during that same week. The content of the text messages show that the two were simply engaged in back and forth arguing over child visitation. Upon viewing such evidence, the prosecution may possibly drop the case. If the charges are not dropped, then this evidence could be presented to the jury.

Retain a Cincinnati defense lawyer for false stalking or menacing charges

If you or a loved one are facing charges that are based on false information then it is important to contact an attorney immediately. Counsel will give you an honest assessment of the situation and how to best defend the charges. Your representative will also give you an honest assessment as to what you should expect from the process. Protecting your rights during such a situation is critical.

I am a Cincinnati stalking and menacing lawyer who believes that everyone is entitled to effective representation. My firm is also able to assist with any accompanying child custody issues. If you or a loved one are in need of assistance then contact us online or by telephone today to schedule an initial consultation. We also handle matters in the southwest Ohio areas of Hamilton, Middletown, Fairfield, Mason, Oxford, and other surrounding cities. These include cases heard in the Municipal Courts of Clermont County, Hamilton County, and Warren County.

Contact Us